| | | Otterbein wins the toss, defers, and will defend the south goal. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal35 | OTT ball on OTT35. |
| | | Nick Ganus kickoff 64 yards to the GAL1, Ryan Bonheyo return 15 yards to the GAL16, out-of-bounds (Jordan Keaton). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal16 | Braxton Baker rush for 2 yards to the GAL18 (Chad Pepper). |
| Gal | 2-8 | at Gal18 | Nick Elstad rush for 4 yards to the GAL22 (Matt Cantrell;Jordan Bonifas). |
| Gal | 3-4 | at Gal22 | Todd Bonheyo pass incomplete to Kevin Berrigan. |
| Gal | 4-4 | at Gal22 | Shelby Bean punt 26 yards to the GAL48, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:41 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal48 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 13:19. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal48 | Brock Burzanko rush for 11 yards to the GAL37, 1ST DOWN OTT (Tom Pangia;T. Canterbury). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal37 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Gabe Shively for 12 yards to the GAL25, 1ST DOWN OTT, out-of-bounds (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal25 | Aaron Kingcade rush for 5 yards to the GAL20 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 2-5 | at Gal20 | Aaron Kingcade pass intercepted by AJ McCrea at the GAL1, AJ McCrea return 0 yards to the GAL1. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 28 yards, TOP 01:49 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal01 | GALLAUDET drive start at 11:30. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal01 | Braxton Baker rush for loss of 1 yard to the GAL0 (Joe Whitehead;P. Seesholtz), Joe Whitehead safety, clock 11:22. |
| | | Otterbein 2, Gallaudet 0 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:09 |
| | | Shelby Bean kickoff 29 yards to the GAL49, out-of-bounds, OTT ball on GAL49. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal49 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 11:21. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal49 | PENALTY GAL illegal procedure 5 yards to the GAL44. |
| Ott | 1-5 | at Gal44 | 1st and 10. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal44 | Brock Burzanko rush for 1 yard to the GAL43 (Jaris Alleyne;Kevin Allen). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Gal43 | Connor Lucas rush for 7 yards to the GAL36 (T. Canterbury;Tom Pangia). |
| Ott | 3-2 | at Gal36 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Gabe Shively for 6 yards to the GAL30, 1ST DOWN OTT (Shelby Bean). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal30 | Aaron Kingcade rush for no gain to the GAL30 (Kevin Allen). |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Gal30 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to Chris Irwin. |
| Ott | 3-10 | at Gal30 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to John Vincent, PENALTY GAL personal foul (Kevin Allen) 15 yards to the GAL15, 1ST DOWN OTT, NO PLAY. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal15 | Connor Lucas rush for loss of 5 yards to the GAL20 (Tom Pangia). |
| Ott | 2-15 | at Gal20 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Connor Lucas for 10 yards to the GAL10 (Tony Tatum). |
| Ott | 3-5 | at Gal10 | Brock Burzanko rush for loss of 4 yards to the GAL14 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 4-9 | at Gal14 | Nick Ganus field goal attempt from 31 GOOD, clock 06:20. |
| | | Otterbein 5, Gallaudet 0 |
| Ott | 1-G | at Ott35 | OTT ball on OTT35. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 35 yards, TOP 05:09 |
| | | Nick Ganus kickoff 59 yards to the GAL6, Ryan Bonheyo return 29 yards to the GAL35 (Matt Cantrell). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal35 | GALLAUDET drive start at 06:12. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal35 | Braxton Baker rush for 6 yards to the GAL41 (Jordan Bonifas). |
| Gal | 2-4 | at Gal41 | Braxton Baker rush for loss of 1 yard to the GAL40 (Patrick Coleman). |
| Gal | 3-5 | at Gal40 | Todd Bonheyo rush for 17 yards to the OTT43, 1ST DOWN GAL, out-of-bounds. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Ott43 | BJ Flores rush for 9 yards to the OTT34 (Wes McKeever). |
| Gal | 2-1 | at Ott34 | BJ Flores rush for 14 yards to the OTT20, 1ST DOWN GAL (Ryan Moore). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Ott20 | Ryan Bonheyo rush for 2 yards to the OTT18, fumble forced by Patrick Coleman, fumble by Ryan Bonheyo recovered by OTT Joe Whitehead at OTT16. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 49 yards, TOP 04:35 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott16 | Clock 02:31. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott16 | Brock Burzanko rush for 4 yards to the OTT20 (Tom Pangia). |
| Ott | 2-6 | at Ott20 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Chris Irwin for 16 yards to the OTT36, fumble forced by Shelby Bean, fumble by Chris Irwin recovered by GAL AJ McCrea at OTT37. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 21 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Ott37 | GALLAUDET drive start at 01:37. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Ott37 | BJ Flores rush for 2 yards to the OTT35 (Zack Grieves). |
| Gal | 2-8 | at Ott35 | Nick Elstad rush for 9 yards to the OTT26, 1ST DOWN GAL, out-of-bounds (Taylor Briggs). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Ott26 | BJ Flores rush for 5 yards to the OTT21 (Shane Little). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Otterbein 5, Gallaudet 0 |
| Gal | 2-5 | at Ott21 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Gal | 2-5 | at Ott21 | Todd Bonheyo rush for 20 yards to the OTT1 (A. Korpieski), PENALTY GAL illegal formation 5 yards to the OTT26, NO PLAY. |
| Gal | 2-10 | at Ott26 | Todd Bonheyo rush for loss of 2 yards to the OTT28 (P. Seesholtz). |
| Gal | 3-12 | at Ott28 | Todd Bonheyo pass complete to Ryne Worsham for 7 yards to the OTT21 (A. Korpieski). |
| Gal | 4-5 | at Ott21 | Chase Magsig field goal attempt from 38 MISSED - wide left, spot at OTT21, clock 12:49. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott21 | Joey Robertson rush for 4 yards to the OTT25 (G. McConville). |
| Ott | 2-6 | at Ott25 | Joey Robertson rush for 1 yard to the OTT26 (Cody Contreras). |
| Ott | 3-5 | at Ott26 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to S. Carpenter for 7 yards to the OTT33, 1ST DOWN OTT, out-of-bounds (AJ McCrea). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott33 | Joey Robertson rush for loss of 5 yards to the OTT28 (Kevin Allen). |
| Ott | 2-15 | at Ott28 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Brice Frentzel for 10 yards to the OTT38 (Nico Santiago). |
| Ott | 3-5 | at Ott38 | Aaron Kingcade rush for 7 yards to the OTT45, 1ST DOWN OTT (T. Canterbury). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott45 | Joey Robertson rush for 1 yard to the OTT46 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Ott46 | Joey Robertson rush for 1 yard to the OTT47 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 3-8 | at Ott47 | Ben Sizemore rush for 27 yards to the GAL26, 1ST DOWN OTT (T. Canterbury). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal26 | Ben Sizemore rush for 1 yard to the GAL25 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Gal25 | Ben Sizemore pass complete to S. Carpenter for 2 yards to the GAL23 (T. Canterbury). |
| Ott | 3-7 | at Gal23 | Ben Sizemore pass incomplete to S. Carpenter. |
| Ott | 4-7 | at Gal23 | Nick Ganus field goal attempt from 40 MISSED - short, spot at GAL23, clock 05:22. |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 56 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal23 | Braxton Baker rush for 7 yards to the GAL30 (Shane Little). |
| Gal | 2-3 | at Gal30 | Braxton Baker rush for 8 yards to the GAL38, 1ST DOWN GAL (Chad Pepper). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal38 | Braxton Baker rush for no gain to the GAL38 (E. Bergenstein). |
| Gal | 2-10 | at Gal38 | Braxton Baker rush for 1 yard to the GAL39 (Zack Grieves;S. Brintlinger). |
| Gal | 3-9 | at Gal39 | Todd Bonheyo pass intercepted by Jaylin Kennedy at the OTT37, Jaylin Kennedy return 2 yards to the OTT39 (Ryne Worsham). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott39 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 02:48. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott39 | Brock Burzanko rush for 4 yards to the OTT43 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 2-6 | at Ott43 | Brock Burzanko rush for 7 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN OTT (Shelby Bean). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott50 | Ben Sizemore rush for 6 yards to the GAL44 (Adham Talaat). |
| Ott | 2-4 | at Gal44 | Derik Rudolph rush for 4 yards to the GAL40, 1ST DOWN OTT (Kevin Allen). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal40 | Derik Rudolph rush for 6 yards to the GAL34 (Cody Contreras), Ben Sizemore rush for 12 yards to the GAL22, 1ST DOWN OTT, out-of-bounds. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal22 | Timeout Gallaudet, clock 00:58. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal22 | Brock Burzanko pass incomplete to Chris Irwin (Shelby Bean). |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Gal22 | Aaron Kingcade pass intercepted by Tony Tatum at the GAL5, Tony Tatum return 16 yards to the GAL21 (Aaron Kingcade). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 39 yards, TOP 02:05 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal21 | GALLAUDET drive start at 00:43. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal21 | Braxton Baker rush for 3 yards to the GAL24 (Chad Pepper). |
| Gal | 2-7 | at Gal24 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:43 |
| | | Otterbein 5, Gallaudet 0 |
| Gal | 2-7 | at Gal24 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Gal | 2-7 | at Gal24 | GAL ball on GAL35. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:43 |
| | | Chase Magsig kickoff 43 yards to the OTT22, Alex Cameron return 29 yards to the GAL49, out-of-bounds (Akeem Guidry), PENALTY GAL face mask (Akeem Guidry) 15 yards to the GAL34, 1st and 10, OTT ball on GAL34. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal34 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 14:51. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal34 | Brock Burzanko rush for 15 yards to the GAL19, 1ST DOWN OTT, out-of-bounds (Tony Tatum). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal19 | Brock Burzanko rush for loss of 1 yard to the GAL20 (Kevin Allen). |
| Ott | 2-11 | at Gal20 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to Chris Irwin. |
| Ott | 3-11 | at Gal20 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to S. Carpenter. |
| Ott | 4-11 | at Gal20 | Nick Ganus field goal attempt from 37 GOOD, clock 13:19. |
| | | Otterbein 8, Gallaudet 0 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 14 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| | | Nick Ganus kickoff 57 yards to the GAL8, Nick Elstad return 20 yards to the GAL28 (Eric Mitchell). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal28 | GALLAUDET drive start at 13:14. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal28 | Nick Elstad pass incomplete to Ryne Worsham, PENALTY OTT roughing passer (P. Seesholtz) 15 yards to the GAL43, 1ST DOWN GAL, NO PLAY. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal43 | Braxton Baker rush for 5 yards to the GAL48 (P. Seesholtz). |
| Gal | 2-5 | at Gal48 | Braxton Baker rush for 3 yards to the OTT49 (Zack Grieves). |
| Gal | 3-2 | at Ott49 | Todd Bonheyo sacked for loss of 4 yards to the GAL47 (P. Seesholtz). |
| Gal | 4-6 | at Gal47 | Shelby Bean punt 36 yards to the OTT17, downed, PENALTY GAL kick catching interference 18 yards to the OTT35, 1st and 10, OTT ball on OTT35. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 19 yards, TOP 02:28 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott35 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 10:46. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott35 | Joey Robertson rush for 2 yards to the OTT37 (C. Richardson). |
| Ott | 2-8 | at Ott37 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to Brice Frentzel. |
| Ott | 3-8 | at Ott37 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Grant Smith for 3 yards to the OTT40 (Nico Santiago). |
| Ott | 4-5 | at Ott40 | Aaron Kingcade punt 60 yards to the GAL0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:31 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal20 | GALLAUDET drive start at 09:15. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal20 | Ryan Bonheyo rush for 9 yards to the GAL29 (A. Korpieski). |
| Gal | 2-1 | at Gal29 | BJ Flores rush for 15 yards to the GAL44, 1ST DOWN GAL (Wes McKeever). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal44 | Braxton Baker rush for 3 yards to the GAL47 (Zack Grieves;Matt Cantrell). |
| Gal | 2-7 | at Gal47 | BJ Flores rush for no gain to the GAL47 (Joe Whitehead). |
| Gal | 3-7 | at Gal47 | BJ Flores rush for 4 yards to the OTT49 (Chad Pepper). |
| Gal | 4-3 | at Ott49 | Timeout Otterbein, clock 06:02. |
| Gal | 4-3 | at Ott49 | Shelby Bean pass complete to Adham Talaat for no gain to the OTT49 (Jordan Bonifas). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 31 yards, TOP 03:21 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott49 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 05:54. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott49 | Aaron Kingcade rush for no gain to the OTT49 (Jared Pearce). |
| Ott | 2-10 | at Ott49 | Aaron Kingcade rush for 1 yard to the 50 yardline (Nico Santiago). |
| Ott | 3-9 | at Ott50 | Aaron Kingcade pass incomplete to S. Carpenter. |
| Ott | 4-9 | at Ott50 | Aaron Kingcade punt 50 yards to the GAL0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:14 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal20 | GALLAUDET drive start at 04:40. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal20 | BJ Flores rush for 5 yards to the GAL25 (Ryan Moore). |
| Gal | 2-5 | at Gal25 | Ryan Bonheyo rush for 9 yards to the GAL34, 1ST DOWN GAL (Ryan Moore). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal34 | Nick Elstad rush for 5 yards to the GAL39, out-of-bounds (Jordan Bonifas). |
| Gal | 2-5 | at Gal39 | BJ Flores rush for 2 yards to the GAL41 (Joe Whitehead). |
| Gal | 3-3 | at Gal41 | BJ Flores rush for 2 yards to the GAL43 (Joe Whitehead;Eric Mitchell). |
| Gal | 4-1 | at Gal43 | Ryan Bonheyo rush for no gain to the GAL43 (P. Seesholtz). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 23 yards, TOP 03:07 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal43 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 01:33. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal43 | Joey Robertson rush for 1 yard to the GAL42 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Gal42 | Joey Robertson rush for loss of 2 yards to the GAL44 (Tom Pangia). |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 05:15 |
| | | Otterbein 8, Gallaudet 0 |
| Ott | 3-11 | at Gal44 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Ott | 3-11 | at Gal44 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to S. Carpenter for 11 yards to the GAL33, out-of-bounds (Shelby Bean), PENALTY OTT illegal block 10 yards to the GAL43. |
| Ott | 3-10 | at Gal43 | 3rd and 10. |
| Ott | 3-10 | at Gal43 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Grant Smith for 21 yards to the GAL22, 1ST DOWN OTT (AJ McCrea). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal22 | Joey Robertson rush for 4 yards to the GAL18 (Shelby Bean). |
| Ott | 2-6 | at Gal18 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to S. Carpenter for 10 yards to the GAL8, 1ST DOWN OTT, out-of-bounds (Shelby Bean). |
| Ott | 1-G | at Gal08 | Joey Robertson rush for 5 yards to the GAL3 (Adham Talaat). |
| Ott | 2-G | at Gal03 | Joey Robertson rush for loss of 1 yard to the GAL4 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 3-G | at Gal04 | Timeout Otterbein, clock 11:32. |
| Ott | 3-G | at Gal04 | Aaron Kingcade rush for 4 yards to the GAL0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:26. |
| | | Nick Ganus kick attempt good. |
| | | Otterbein 15, Gallaudet 0 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 43 yards, TOP 05:15 |
| | | Nick Ganus kickoff 59 yards to the GAL6, Ryan Bonheyo return 15 yards to the GAL21 (Taylor Briggs), PENALTY GAL holding (Kevin Berrigan) 10 yards to the GAL11, 1st and 10, GAL ball on GAL11. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal11 | GALLAUDET drive start at 11:18. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal11 | Todd Bonheyo pass complete to Nick Elstad for 11 yards to the GAL22, 1ST DOWN GAL, out-of-bounds. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal22 | Braxton Baker rush for 5 yards to the GAL27 (P. Seesholtz). |
| Gal | 2-5 | at Gal27 | Todd Bonheyo pass incomplete to Ryne Worsham. |
| Gal | 3-5 | at Gal27 | Todd Bonheyo pass complete to Nick Elstad for 14 yards to the GAL41, 1ST DOWN GAL (Chad Pepper). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal41 | Todd Bonheyo pass incomplete to Ryan Bonheyo. |
| Gal | 2-10 | at Gal41 | Braxton Baker rush for 4 yards to the GAL45 (Matt Cantrell;Patrick Coleman). |
| Gal | 3-6 | at Gal45 | Todd Bonheyo pass complete to Kevin Berrigan for 10 yards to the OTT45, 1ST DOWN GAL, out-of-bounds (Matt Cantrell). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Ott45 | Ryan Bonheyo rush for loss of 1 yard to the OTT46 (Shane Little). |
| Gal | 2-11 | at Ott46 | Timeout Gallaudet, clock 07:29. |
| Gal | 2-11 | at Ott46 | BJ Flores rush for loss of 4 yards to the 50 yardline, out-of-bounds (Zack Grieves). |
| Gal | 3-15 | at Gal50 | Todd Bonheyo rush for 7 yards to the OTT43, out-of-bounds (Chad Pepper). |
| Gal | 4-8 | at Ott43 | Timeout Gallaudet, clock 06:16. |
| Gal | 4-8 | at Ott43 | Todd Bonheyo pass intercepted by Jaylin Kennedy at the OTT30, Jaylin Kennedy return 17 yards to the OTT47, out-of-bounds (Braxton Baker). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 46 yards, TOP 05:14 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott47 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 06:04. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Ott47 | Brock Burzanko rush for 5 yards to the GAL48 (Shelby Bean). |
| Ott | 2-5 | at Gal48 | Brock Burzanko rush for loss of 1 yard to the GAL49 (Tom Pangia). |
| Ott | 3-6 | at Gal49 | Aaron Kingcade pass complete to Gabe Shively for 11 yards to the GAL38, 1ST DOWN OTT (Nico Santiago). |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal38 | Brock Burzanko rush for 1 yard to the GAL37 (Jaris Alleyne). |
| Ott | 2-9 | at Gal37 | Brock Burzanko rush for 1 yard to the GAL36 (C. Richardson). |
| Ott | 3-8 | at Gal36 | Timeout Gallaudet, clock 02:43. |
| Ott | 3-8 | at Gal36 | Brock Burzanko rush for loss of 1 yard to the GAL37 (Tom Pangia). |
| Ott | 4-9 | at Gal37 | Aaron Kingcade punt 33 yards to the GAL4, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 16 yards, TOP 04:18 |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal04 | GALLAUDET drive start at 01:46. |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal04 | Todd Bonheyo rush for 9 yards to the GAL13 (Eric Mitchell). |
| Gal | 2-1 | at Gal13 | Braxton Baker rush for 10 yards to the GAL23, 1ST DOWN GAL (Tyler Mautz). |
| Gal | 1-10 | at Gal23 | Todd Bonheyo pass incomplete to Kevin Berrigan. |
| Gal | 2-10 | at Gal23 | Ryan Bonheyo rush for 7 yards to the GAL30 (E. Bergenstein). |
| Gal | 3-3 | at Gal30 | Todd Bonheyo pass incomplete to Nick Elstad (Eric Mitchell). |
| Gal | 4-3 | at Gal30 | Todd Bonheyo sacked for loss of 5 yards to the GAL25 (Zack Grieves). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 21 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal25 | OTTERBEIN drive start at 00:25. |
| Ott | 1-10 | at Gal25 | Team rush for loss of 2 yards to the GAL27. |
| Ott | 2-12 | at Gal27 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 00:25 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Otterbein 15, Gallaudet 0 |